A Florida Family Protecting Florida Families
For more than 40 years, Peeples Insurance has been a trusted name in Southwest Florida — built on personal service, honest advice, and deep local roots.
Years Serving Florida
Insurance Carriers
Coverage Types
Florida Offices
Rooted in the Community We Serve
What started as a local Sarasota agency has grown into three Florida offices — but our philosophy has never changed. We treat every client like a neighbor, because most of them are.
As an independent agency, we work for you, not the insurance companies. We shop 95+ carriers to find coverage matched to Florida's unique risks — hurricanes, flooding, windstorm, and more.
From securing emergency coverage on Christmas Eve to saving families thousands on their premiums, our team goes the extra mile every single day.
Jennifer Peeples Winkler
Agency Owner
Jennifer is the heart of Peeples Insurance. Named in review after review for her extraordinary responsiveness and care, she has built the agency's reputation on a simple promise: treat every client like family and never stop until they're protected.
“She quickly assured me not to worry — and got my home covered on Christmas Eve. What a blessing she was to me.”— Angelique B., Homeowners client[email protected]
The Peeples Insurance Team
Friendly, licensed, and local — the faces behind your coverage across all three offices.
Sarasota Office
Jennifer Peeples Winkler
Agency Owner
The heart of Peeples Insurance, Jennifer is celebrated by clients for going above and beyond — including securing emergency coverage on Christmas Eve. She leads the agency with a personal, service-first philosophy.
[email protected]Katie Bird
Operations Manager
Katie keeps every office running smoothly, ensuring clients receive fast, accurate service from quote to policy.
Mary Mapp
Consultant
Mary brings seasoned insurance knowledge to help clients understand coverage options and make confident decisions.
Karen Mullins
Receptionist
Often the first friendly voice clients hear, Karen makes sure every visitor and caller is warmly welcomed.
Lena Rose
Licensed Insurance Agent
Lena helps individuals and families find tailored coverage across home, auto, and specialty lines.
Dianne Tucker
Licensed Insurance Agent
Dianne specializes in matching Florida clients with the right carriers from our network of 95+ companies.
Talon Riley
Licensed Insurance Agent
Talon combines local knowledge with a proactive approach to protecting his clients’ assets.
Nick Granieri
Licensed Client Service Representative
Nick supports clients through renewals, changes, and claims with responsive, friendly service.
Bradenton Office
Javier Ordonez
Licensed Insurance Agent
Javier serves the Bradenton community with bilingual, personalized insurance guidance.
Gwen Evans
Licensed Insurance Agent
Gwen helps Bradenton families and businesses secure comprehensive, competitively priced coverage.
Bryce Robertson
Licensed Insurance Agent
Bryce focuses on finding smart coverage solutions for homeowners and drivers across the region.
Susan Whipple
Administrative Assistant
Susan keeps the Bradenton office organized and clients’ paperwork moving quickly.
Tyler Walrond
Client Service Representative
Tyler is dedicated to responsive support, handling client requests with care and speed.
Margate Office
Tea Peeples
Manager
Tea leads the Margate office, bringing the same trusted, family-first service to South Florida clients.
[email protected]Jill Shartle
Agent
Jill helps Margate-area clients navigate coverage options with clarity and care.
Dominique Marcel
Client Service Representative
Dominique provides attentive, day-to-day service for Margate policyholders.